Beauty

Beauty leaders push context and consistency to counter misinformation

Dalia MansourOctober 27, 20265 min read4 views

At a glance

  • At the CTPA's first scientific conference, regulators, researchers and journalists debated how to explain cosmetic science to uncertain consumers.
  • Speakers at the CTPA's inaugural scientific conference in London called for clearer context, consistent messaging and better explanations of peer review to counter beauty misinformation, while cautioning that the industry should focus on undecided consumers rather than entrenched critics.
A glass beaker, a single suspended droplet and a miniature swimming pool sit beside unlabeled cosmetic bottles and a magnifying glass over a blank ingredient panel.

Government officials, industry researchers and journalists gathered at the UK Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association's (CTPA) first scientific conference to discuss how the beauty sector can counter misinformation and engage the public, media and consumers. The members-only event was held at Central Hall Westminster in London.

In opening remarks, Caroline Rainsford, director of science at the CTPA, said strong science communication is essential, noting that people across the field spend their days translating complicated scientific information into something audiences can manage and understand.

Putting risk into context

Speaking on a panel about building trust through science communication, Rainsford said placing science in context is consistently useful. She recalled explaining to salon professionals that an ingredient banned in nail polish would require wearing roughly two kilograms of the product to approach the level associated with harm — an example she said speaks to people.

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, agreed on the importance of context and offered the Olympic swimming pool analogy for communicating very small concentrations: at two litres a day, drinking a single pool would take about 4,500 years. Once that is explained, he said, people understand that a drop in a pool is negligible. To fight misinformation, the industry must first explain and give consumers the means to measure and understand, he added.

One voice and its limits

Pissavini argued that credibility in science requires consistency, calling on dermatologists, doctors and companies to speak with one voice — shifting from “I” to “we”, as pharmacy and large groups do — which he said would make the sector stronger.

Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government's Office for Product Safety and Standards, said the idea of a single voice is interesting but that scientists are not especially good at it. She noted that credible science rests on critique and peer review, and said the profession should become more aware of how it communicates with itself.

Pissavini, who also edits the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said preserving peer review is crucial, though the challenge today is finding reviewers and communicating better with readers both inside and outside the industry. Rainsford added that the sector must work collectively to demystify peer review, since many people — including some within the industry — do not understand how the process works, making transparency important.

Meeting consumers where they are

Journalist and consultant Claire Coleman said efforts should begin where misinformation is found, meeting people on the same platform. She argued the industry should not target hard-liners but rather “floating voters” — consumers who are uncertain and want to understand better.

Middleton agreed that meeting people where they are is critical. Government, she said, once spoke of hard-to-reach consumers, but they are not hard to reach; they are hard for institutions to hear, which requires taking more responsibility for listening.

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK Chemical Industries Association, advised avoiding technical terms and acronyms where possible, framing messages precisely and clearly from the consumer's perspective without losing the science — a tricky goal with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure. He added that science is not always black and white, and that transparency means acknowledging uncertainties and being upfront about what remains unknown.

CTPA director-general Emma Meredith closed the event by saying that how the industry communicates science, and that it does so well, is critical.

Reported by Dalia Mansour, Beauty Product Sourcing Analyst.