The Packaging Scheme Forum (PSF) has launched a campaign to modernise the UK's packaging recycling system, warning that abolishing Packaging Recycling Notes (PRNs) without a workable replacement would risk "creating chaos" across the sector.
The initiative, called "Keep Packaging Recycling Working", was announced as media reports suggested supermarkets and manufacturers were working ahead of the Budget to demand that the PRN system be scrapped. Critics have characterised PRNs as a packaging or plastic tax.
Three decades of hitting targets
The PSF, which represents 13 of the 15 existing compliance scheme operators, said the current PRN system has helped the UK consistently meet its statutory packaging recycling targets for three decades. It described the mechanism as responsive, supporting recycling businesses, encouraging investment and enabling producers to meet their environmental obligations.
The body argued that wholesale reform on the scale proposed by the food and drink sector would be a "reckless gamble with Britain's recycling industry". It pointed to £95m of PRN revenue last year committed to new recycling infrastructure and capacity across the UK.
Recycling evidence, not a tax
George Atkinson, director of policy at Valpak and chair of the PSF, rejected the tax label. "To clarify, those calling PRNs a plastic 'tax' are overlooking what they actually do and the materials the system ensures environmentally-positive outcomes for," he said. "PRNs are recycling evidence, not a tax paid into the Exchequer. The money flows into the recycling system through accredited reprocessors and exporters and helps make the economics of recycling work."
He warned that removing PRNs without a viable alternative in place would risk destabilising financial flows into the waste management industry, undermining business and investor confidence and putting critical national infrastructure at risk.
The PSF said PRN revenues supported the £1bn redevelopment of the Shotton Mill on Deeside to produce recycled cardboard packaging and tissue paper.
According to the body, the system has driven UK packaging recycling rates from estimates of 27-30% since 1997 to 70% in 2025, and currently supports the recycling of around 7.7m tonnes of UK packaging waste every year.
Improve what needs improving
The PSF acknowledged that improvements were needed, but said these did not require dismantling the existing system, which it argued would be extremely expensive for the government to execute. Atkinson said there was a legitimate debate about how to make the system work better, citing support for measures that improve transparency over how producers' contributions are reinvested, ensure fair competition between UK reprocessors and exporters, and strengthen market confidence.
He said there was "a very big difference" between improving a system and abolishing it before anyone had demonstrated how its essential functions would be replaced, how different materials would be supported when markets are weak, and how value for money for those obligated would be assured.
Atkinson also argued that scrapping PRNs would not remove costs from the system for producers. "PRNs power the proven recycling of packaging that's otherwise uneconomical to recycle," he said. Without them, the challenge of recycling enough packaging waste to meet national targets would remain, and a fixed cost system would likely cost producers more than one in which the financial stimulus can adjust according to market need.
"The answer to a system that needs fixing is to fix it, not dismantle it and hope for the best," he added.
